My favorite story in The Best From Fantasy and Science Fiction, 23rd SERIES is John Varley’s “In the Hall of the Martian Kings,” a story of a exploration of the Red Planet with a lot of problems. I also liked Jane Yolen’s “Brother Hart” involving shape-shifting and sadness.
Edward L. Ferman continues the inclusion of The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction “Competition” entries. You may or may not like them. I’m not a fan.
I did like Joanna Russ’s essay on “Books: In Defense of Criticism” which extends the discussion beyond Fantasy and SF. Thought-provoking!
The Best From Fantasy and Science Fiction, 23rd Series is the penultimate volume in this long-running anthology series. Next mouth, the final volume…after two years of monthly reviews on this blog! GRADE: B
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
- Introduction (The Best from Fantasy and Science Fiction 23rd Series) • (1980) • essay by Edward L. Ferman
- 1 • I See You • (1976) • short story by Damon Knight
- 15 • From Competition 13: Excerpts from myopic early sf novels • (1976) • essay by Janet E. Pearson
- 15 • From Competition 13: Excerpts from myopic early sf novels • (1976) • essay by David T. J. Doughan
- 17 • The Detweiler Boy • (1977) • novelette by Tom Reamy
- 51 • Books: In Defense of Criticism • (1979) • essay by Joanna Russ
- 59 • Zorphwar! • (1977) • short story by Stan Dryer
- 69 • From Competition 14: SF “What’s the Question” Jokes • (1976) • essay by Bruce Berges
- 69 • From Competition 14: SF “What’s the Question” Jokes • (1976) • essay by J. G. Sattler
- 69 • From Competition 14: SF “What’s the Question” Jokes • (1976) • essay by Steve Steinberg
- 70 • From Competition 14: SF “What’s the question” jokes • (1976) • essay by Mary H. Schaub
- 70 • From Competition 14: SF “What’s the question” jokes • (1976) • essay by Chris Leithiser
- 71 • Stone • (1978) • short story by Edward Bryant
- 89 • From Competition 15: Retranslated sf titles • (1977) • essay by Michael Bishop
- 89 • From Competition 15: Retranslated sf titles • (1977) • essay by Chris Reisbeck
- 89 • From Competition 15: Retranslated sf titles • (1977) • essay by Cambridge University Science Fiction Society
- 90 • From Competition 15: Retranslated sf titles • (1977) • essay by John Billingsley
- 90 • From Competition 15: Retranslated SF Titles • (1977) • essay by Daniel P. Dern
- 91 • Nina • (1977) • short story by Robert Bloch
- 101 • Clone, Clone of My Own • [Asimov’s Essays: F&SF] • (1979) • essay by Isaac Asimov
- 113 • In the Hall of the Martian Kings • (1976) • novella by John Varley
- 155 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by Al Sarrantonio
- 155 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by Harvey Abramson
- 155 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by Lynn Pederson and Wes Pederson
- 155 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by Marc Russell
- 156 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by David Lubar
- 156 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by Barry N. Malzberg
- 156 • From Competition 18: Transposed sf titles • (1978) • essay by Jeremy Hole
- 157 • Upstart • (1977) • short story by Steven Utley
- 161 • A House Divided • [Aventine] • (1978) • short story by Lee Killough
- 183 • From Competition 19: SF limericks • (1978) • essay by Doris McElfresh
- 183 • From Competition 19: SF limericks • (1978) • essay by Margery Goldstein
- 183 • From Competition 19: SF limericks • (1978) • essay by David Lubar
- 184 • From Competition 19: SF limericks • (1978) • essay by Phoebe Ellis
- 185 • Brother Hart • (1978) • short story by Jane Yolen
- 193 • Films: Multiples • (1980) • essay by Baird Searles
- 197 • The Man Who Had No Idea • (1978) • novelette by Thomas M. Disch
- 231 • Project Hi-Rise • (1978) • short story by Robert F. Young
- 243 • Prismatica • (1977) • novelette by Samuel R. Delany