

At a 1942 pre-Broadway performance of Oklahoma! in New Haven, Broadway producer Mike Todd walked out at the Intermission and famously quipped: “No girls. No gags, No chance.” Yes, Oklahoma! does not feature the chorus line of dancing girls most musicals of that time had in abundance. It has some humor, but much of it is dark. Needless to say, Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! went on to win a Pulitzer Prize and changed the history of musical theater.
Diane and I donned our N95 masks and went to see this “new” version of Oklahoma! at the Shea’s Performing Arts Center. Director Daniel Fish “reimagines” Oklahoma! with a racially diverse cast, a stripped down bluegrass band instead of an orchestra, and a focus on brooding farmhand, Jud Fry, who is obsessed with his employer, farm girl Laurey.
After we watched this musical version of Oklahoma! on the stage, Diane and I decided to go back and watch the 1955 movie version with Shirley Jones (her first major role) as Lauren and Gordon MacRae as Curly, the cowboy who loves her. Rod Steiger plays the obsessed farmhand, Jud Fry. Disney+ offered Oklahoma! in brilliant color and excellent sound. The movie version contains the dark elements that the “reimagined” play version accentuates, but the focus is on the young couples and romance instead of the obsessive, creepy Jud Fry. Diane and I both prefer the movie version. Do you like Oklahoma!?
MUSICAL GRADE: C–
MOVIE VERSION: B+
Musical numbers:
- “Overture” – Orchestra (played before the film actually begins)
- “Main Title” – Orchestra (played over the opening credits)
- “Oh What a Beautiful Mornin’” – Curly
- “Laurey’s Entrance” – Laurey (“Oh What a Beautiful Mornin’“)
- “The Surrey With the Fringe On Top” – Curly
- “The Surrey With the Fringe On Top (Reprise)” – Curly
- “Kansas City” – Will, Aunt Eller, Male Ensemble
- “I Cain’t Say No” – Ado Annie
- “I Cain’t Say No” (reprise) – Will and Ado Annie
- “Entrance of Ensemble” (“Oh What a Beautiful Mornin’“) – Curly, Gertie, and Ensemble
- “Many a New Day” – Laurey and Female Ensemble
- “People Will Say We’re In Love” – Curly and Laurey
- “Pore Jud Is Daid” – Curly and Jud
- “Out of My Dreams” – Laurey and Female Ensemble
- “Dream Ballet” – Ensemble
- “Entr’acte” – Orchestra
- “The Farmer and the Cowman” – Carnes, Aunt Eller, Ike Skidmore, Ensemble
- “All Er Nuthin’” – Will and Ado Annie
- “People Will Say We’re In Love (Reprise)” – Curly and Laurey
- “Oklahoma” – Curly and Ensemble
- “Finale Ultimo” (“Oh What a Beautiful Mornin'”) – Ensemble
- “Exit Music” – Orchestra










