
My favorite story in Murder for Halloween (1994) is Edward D. Hoch’s clever Nick Velvet heist, “The Theft of the Halloween Pumpkin.” Nick Velvet only steals worthless items so when a woman wants to hire him to steal a Halloween pumpkin, Velvet accepts. Only later does Velvet learn that sometimes a Halloween pumpkin can be more than a pumpkin.
I also enjoyed Ellery Queen’s “The Adventure of the Dead Cat” where a game at a Halloween Party turns deadly. Steven Saylor, who specializes in crime-solving in the Roman Empire, delivers “The Lemures,” a story about lemures (aka, the unquiet dead) and murderous deception.
It was fun to reread Robert Bloch’s “The Cloak,” a story he wrote back in 1939. Vampires are involved. Gahan Wilson, best known for his cartoons, made me laugh with “Yesterday’s Witch,” with a witch named Miss Marbles (a sly nod to Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple).
Murder for Halloween offers a variety of stories with various settings and characters. If you’re in the mood for Halloween stories with an edge, Murder for Halloween certainly provides some memorial tales! GRADE: B+
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
PREFACE — xiii
Monsters / Ed McBain — 1
The lemures / Steven Saylor — 9
The adventure of the dead cat / Ellery Queen — 43
The odstock curse / Peter Lovesey — 65
The theft of the Halloween pumpkin / Edward D. Hoch — 81
Hallowe’en for Mr. Faulkner / August Derleth — 99
Deceptions / Marcia Muller — 111
The black cat / Edgar Allan Poe — 135
Omjagod / James Grady — 147
The cloak / Robert Bloch — 173
What a woman wants / Michael Z. Lewin — 191
Yesterday’s witch / Gahan Wilson — 211
Walpurgis night / Bram Stoker — 221
Trick or treat / Judith Garner — 237
One night at a time / Dorothy Cannell — 243
Night of the goblin / Talmage Powell — 267
Trick-or-treat / Anthony Boucher — 279
Pork pie hat / Peter Straub — 297
ABOUT THE EDITORS — 363