
I first read Ursula K. Le Guin back in the 1960s. Ace Books released Rocannon’s World, Le Guin’s first published novel, in 1966. Two more Hainish novels, Planet of Exile and City of Illusions were published in 1966 and 1967, respectively, and the three books together would come to be known as the Hainish trilogy. But Le Guin then made the bold move to write fantasy novels: A Wizard of Earthsea, published in 1968,
The Le Guin novel that really captured my interest was her next novel, The Left Hand of Darkness, set in her Hainish universe. The story explored themes of gender and sexuality on a fictional planet where humans have no fixed sex. The book was Le Guin’s first to address feminist issues, and according to scholar Donna White, it “stunned the science fiction critics”; it won both the Hugo and the Nebula Awards for best novel, making Le Guin the first woman to win both these awards,
In his “Introduction” Jonathan Strahan praises Ursula K. Le Guin and writes that the stories he has collected in this anthology are tributes to her. I don’t claim to be a Le Guin scholar, but I’m mystified by most of these stories. They seem to have little to do with Le Guin’s concerns as far as I can tell.
The two best stories in this book are The Monster’s Story by Kelly Link and Beaumont by Karen Joy Fowler. Again, I’m not sure what these stories have to do with Le Guin and her work, but they are solid stories. It would have been helpful if Strahan or the authors had written mini-introductions to the stories explaining what they had to do with Le Guin’s work. GRADE: C
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
INTRODUCTION by Jonathan Strahan –1
- Five-eyed Jane by Ann Leckie — 3
- The Weak Ask, the Strong Know by Charlie Jane Anders — 19
- Homestead by Molly Gloss — 41
- Travelling, Home by Sarah Pinsker — 53
- Many Light Objects by Chana Porter — 75
- Late Sowers by Alaya Dawn Johnson — 91
- Hold Me Close to Your Heart by S. Qiouyi Lu — 117
- Shell in the Desert by E. Lily Yu — 149
- Dark Below by Vandana Singh — 159
- Sliver of a door. A gasp allowed free or muffled? by Ai Jiang — 181
- In One Substance by Aliya Whiteley — 199
- River Run Riot Run Dry by Premee Mohamed — 223
- Soloist Nell by Darcie Little Badger — 247
- The Monster’s Story by Kelly Link — 261
- Beaumont by Karen Joy Fowler — 287
About the Authors — 303
About the Editor — 309
Acknowledgments — 311
While I appreciate Le Guin and enjoy much of her work, I do not seek her stories out. I used to read her 1988 children’s book FIRE AND STONE to first and second graders, using a normal voice through most of it, then letting out the dragon’s roar (“RAWK!”) at the top of my voice, startling both the kids, the teachers, and (often) several nearby classes — it was always a hit. I think “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” was the best thing she wrote.
Jerry, Ursula Le Guin broke a lot of ground in the SF and Fantasy markets for other women writers. I wish I could have been there to hear your “dragon” roar!