I’ve been a fan of Martin Edwards’s mystery anthologies for years. Who Killed Father Christmas and Other Seasonal Mysteries is the fifth Christmas anthology Edwards has published with the British Library Crime Classics (aka, Poisoned Pen Press). The other four anthologies are Silent Nights, Crimson Snow, The Christmas Card Crime, and A Surprise for Christmas.

I also enjoyed the title story, Patricia Moyes’s “Who Killed Father Christmas” about the murder of a department store Santa. My favorite story in this anthology is “Secrets in the Snow” by J. Jefferson Farjeon. Since it’s snowing now outside my window, the story resonated with me.

Who Killed Father Christmas (2025) blends a number of various Christmas mysteries, some serious, some not. I enjoyed Peter Todd’s clever “Herlock Sholmes’ Christmas Case.” Back in 1976, Mysterious Press published The Adventures of Herlock Sholmes, but this story wasn’t included.

If you’re in the mood for a Christmas mystery anthology, Who Killed Father Christmas and Other Seasonal Mysteries should be at the top of your wish list. GRADE: B

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

• Introduction / Martin Edwards — vii
• A Note From the Publisher –xi
• On the Irish Mail / Garnett Radcliffe — 1
• The Christmas Thief / Frank Howel Evans — 16
• The Christmas Spirit / Anthony Gilbert — 50
• Among Those Present Was Santa Claus / Vincent Cornier — 69
• Gold, Frankincense, and Murder / Catherine Aird — 80
• Secrets in the Snow / J. Jefferson Farjeon — 101
• Who Killed Father Christmas? / Patricia Moyes — 123
• Death at Christmas / Glyn Daniel — 137
• Scotland Yard’s Christmas / John Dickson Carr — 152
• The Bird of Dawning / Michael Gilbert — 165
• The Christmas Train / Will Scott — 186
• The Grey Monk / Gerald Verner — 202
• Who Suspects the Postman? / Michael Innes — 214
• Herlock Sholmes’ Christmas Case / Peter Todd — 221
• A Present for Ivo / Ellis Peters — 230

I DVRed all six episodes of PBS Masterpiece‘s Wolf Hall: The Mirror and the Light last year. The sticking point was finding time to read Hilary Mantel’s 761 page novel that the series was based on. Fortunately, I finally read Mantel’s tome from 2020 while waiting eight hours at the Buffalo Airport for Diane and her sister Carol to arrive from JFK during the Government Shutdown.

The Mirror and the Light is the third book in Hilary Mantel’s Thomas Cromwell trilogy (you can read my reviews of Wolf Hall (2009) and Bring Up the Bodies (2012) here). Mantel’s story of the rise and fall of Thomas Cromwell is chilling. King Henry VIII is a psychopath whose moods can lead to someone dying. Henry Tudor, played brilliantly by Damian Lewis, faces popular unrest as a result of his break with Rome and the establishment of the Church of England. Henry also needs a son. Wolf Hall: The Mirror and the Light starts with an execution so Henry can marry again.

Mark Rylance plays the dutiful Thomas Cromwell with great authenticity. Cromwell knows he serves a half-mad King and an England perilously in danger of internal dissension and foreign intrigue. Throughout the PBS series and Mantel’s historical novels, the treacherous path of power in the Court threatens Cromwell despite his successes.

Maybe it’s just the times we live in, but Henry VIII acts in very Trumpian ways. He rages, he threatens, he kills, he commits incredible cruelties, he dresses up in an absurd Turkish costume. Cromwell is urged to leave England and return to Antwerp where he once found happiness by a family member. But Cromwell stays and accepts his Fate.

If you’re a fan of historical dramas, you’ll love this Thomas Crowell trilogy. But be prepared to endure some pain and suffering at the atrocities committed by the King and his duplicitous Court. GRADE: A

“The hypothesis of this book is that suicide epidemics appear wherever a culture based on mutual aid, respect, and belonging suddenly gives way to world of anonymous market transactions, individualism, and formal institutions, and, at the same time, a demonstrative love culture is weak.” (p.115)

Helen C. Epstein’s short but powerful book presents the latest research into suicide. It’s no secret that the Holidays trigger a spike in suicides. But in Chapter 5, “What is Haunting America’s Veterans”, I learned the vast majority of veterans who had taken their lives were abused as children. In Chapter 3, “Russia’s Traumatic Transition”, I learned that half the men in Russia are alcoholics–and that greatly increases the rate of suicides.

Many people who commit suicide suffer from depression…but only 1% of depression sufferers resort to suicide. “The age-adjusted suicide rate in the U.S. was 14.1 per 100,000 in 2023, after reaching 14.2 per 100,000 in 2022. In 2023, men died by suicide at a rate 3.8 times higher than women, and white males accounted for the majority of suicide deaths. The highest age-specific rates were for those aged 85 and older (22.7 per 100,000) and the lowest were for those aged 10–14 (2.3 per 100,000).”

Why Live documents the attempts to deal with suicide as a societal problem. Epstein suggests capitalism, transactional social interactions, and rigid working conditions that steal all creativity and purpose from a job contribute to the problem of suicide. No job, living in poverty, debts, poor health, and a sense of powerlessness makes suicide an attractive option. GRADE: A

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

INTRODUCTION — 8

CHAPTER ONE: The Inuit: The Highest Suicide Rate in the World — 27

CHAPTER TWO: Sturm und Drang in Micronesia — 42

CHAPTER THREE: Russia’s Traumatic Transition –56

CHAPTER FOUR: Deaths of Despair in America’s Heartland — 74

CHAPTER FIVE: What is Haunting American’s Veterans? — 87

CHAPTER SIX: The Arts of Endurance — 100

CONCLUSION — 115

FURTHER READING — 135

ACKNOWLEGEMENTS — 139

NOTES — 140

Temps should be about 20 degrees at the Kick-Off of the Bengals vs. Bills game with a chance of snow. The Bills are favored by 5 1/2 points but their starting lineup is riddled with injuries. The Smart Money (aka, Vegas odds makers) suggest the Bills should run, run, run the ball to keep it out of Joe Burrow’s hands. Burrow has had the Buffalo Bills number in critical games in the Past. Last week, Burrow lit up the Ravens. Will he do it again to the Bills?

How will your favorite NFL team fare today?

If you decide to watch Oh. What. Fun.–AMAZON Prime Video’s new Christmas movie–do yourself a favor and just watch the last 20 minutes.

Michelle Pfeiffer plays Christmas-obsessed mother, Claire Clauster, who feels–deservedly so–taken for granted by her detached husband (Denis Leary), and her three self-absorbed children: novel writer Channing (Felicity Jones), Taylor (Chloë Grace Moretz) who shows up with a new girl friend every Christmas, and Sammy (Dominic Sessa) whose “job” is yearly three-month stint as a Summer Camp Counselor–in essence, a dud.

While Claire does all the Christmas preparations, her family does nothing to help her. They argue and fight instead. When the family unintentionally abandons Claire–think Home Alone–Claire sets out on her own journey which through some quirks of Fate, makes her an national icon.

Skip the tedious family in-fighting and predictable Christmas nonsense–which is NOT a lot of fun–and go right to the heart of this insipid movie: the last 20 minutes. Or skip the whole movie. GRADE: D (for dumb)

I consider Michael Gambon’s performance of Maigret to be just about perfect. Therefore, seeing a young Benjamin Wainwright  starring as Maigret was a bit disconcerting. I wasn’t sure I wanted to watch this new series…but eventually I relented.

Simenon’s novel was first published in 1961. I reread it before I watched the PBS version. Other than the death of the Lazy Burglar and the bank robbers, the new rendition of Maigret features a good looking Benjamin Wainwright, with a scruffy beard and a shirt that’s never tucked in, investigating crimes while pushing back on the bureaucracy.

Wainwright’s Maigret works in a contemporary Police Station with computers and Internet and all the forensic extras–none of which were in Simenon’s novel. What is kept of Simenon’s chief of detectives is that both the novel and the TV series have a very capable crime solver. I enjoyed the first installment of the PBS Maigret series and will continue watching it. GRADE: B

I’ve been a fan of Kelly Clarkson for some time and decided to give her Christmas album, Wrapped in Red (2013), a listen.

The standard Christmas songs, “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas,” “Run Run Rudolph,” “Please Come Home For Christmas,” “Baby It’s Cold Outside,” “White Christmas,” “My Favorite Things,” and “Silent Night” all sound…Christmassy!

What makes this Christmas album different are the newer songs, and one cover. “Underneath the Tree,” really grabbed my attention. “Winter Dreams” and “Just for Now”–a cover of an Imogen Heap song–are special. If you’re looking for a different Christmas album for the season, you might try this blend of old and new songs sung superbly by Kelly Clarkson. Do you see any of your Christmas favorites here? GRADE: B+

TRACK LIST:

Kelly Clarkson–	Wrapped In Red	3:36
	Kelly Clarkson–	Underneath The Tree	3:49
	Kelly Clarkson–	Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas	3:39
	Kelly Clarkson–	Run Run Rudolph	2:27
	Kelly Clarkson–	Please Come Home For Christmas (Bells Will Be Ringing)	3:19
	Kelly Clarkson–	Every Christmas	3:46
	Kelly Clarkson–	Blue Christmas	2:52
	Kelly Clarkson Featuring Ronnie Dunn–	Baby, It’s Cold Outside	3:01
	Kelly Clarkson–	Winter Dreams (Brandon’s Song)	3:22
	Kelly Clarkson–	White Christmas	3:02
	Kelly Clarkson–	My Favorite Things	2:49
	Kelly Clarkson–	4 Carats	3:28
	Kelly Clarkson–	Just For Now	3:30
	Kelly Clarkson Featuring Reba* And Trisha Yearwood–	Silent Night	4:09

15		I’ll Be Home For Christmas (ITunes Session)Bass – Einar PedersenDrums – Miles McPhersonElectric Piano [Wurlitzer] – Jason HalbertMixed By – Jason HalbertOrgan [Hammond B3] – Jason HalbertPiano – Jason HalbertProgrammed By – Jason HalbertRecorded By – Jason HalbertTrumpet – Leif ShiresWritten-By – Buck Ram, Kim Gannon, Walter Kent	2:55
16		Oh Come, Oh Come EmmanuelKeyboards – Greg KurstinWritten-By [Christmas Carol] – Traditional

I’ve been a fan of the Jack Reacher series by Lee Child for years. Otto Penzler, editor of Mysterious Press, is also a Jack Reacher fan. Otto asked Lee Child if he was interested in a limited, exclusive edition of the Jack Reacher series. Child agreed and the publishing processes began. Otto also asked Child if he would write a short essay for each Jack Reacher volume explaining how the book came about. Child agreed to that, too.

Those short essays have now been collected in Reacher: The Stories Behind the Stories. If you’re a Jack Reacher fan, you’ll be delighted by the detail Child provides about genesis of each Jack Reacher book.

My favorite story in Reacher is how Lee Child wrote Make Me while being observed by an academic who wanted to study Child’s writing process. That is all explained in  Andy Martin’s Reacher Said Nothing: Lee Child and the Making of MAKE ME (2015) (you can read my review here).

And, as a bonus, Reacher includes a new Jack Reacher short story: “A Better Place.”

If you have a Jack Reacher fan on your Gift List, Reacher would be perfect! GRADE: A

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

1INTRODUCTION By Lee Child — ix

2ESSAYS:

2.1Killing Floor (1997) — 1

2.2Die Trying (1998) — 7

2.3Tripwire (1999) — 13

2.4Running Blind (2000) — 21

2.5Echo Burning (2001) — 27

2.6Without Fail (2002) — 33

2.7Persuader (2003) — 39

2.8The Enemy (2004) — 45

2.9One Shot (2005) — 51

2.10The Hard Way (2006) — 59

2.11Bad Luck and Trouble (2007) — 65

2.12Nothing To Lose (2008) — 71

2.13Gone Tomorrow (2009) — 79

2.1461 Hours (2010) — 87

2.15Worth Dying For (2010) — 95

2.16The Affair (2011) — 101

2.17A Wanted Man (2012) — 109

2.18Never Go Back (2013) — 119

2.19Personal (2014) — 129

2.20Make Me (2015) — 139

2.21Night School (2014) — 151

2.22The Midnight Line (2017) — 163

2.23Past Tense (2018) — 173

2.24Blue Moon (2019) — 183

NEW REACHER SHORT STORY

“A Better Place” — 191

Afterword by Otto Penzler –217

I DVRed Moonflower Murders back in 2024. I had read Anthony Horowitz’s book of the same title back in 2020. Moonflower Murders is the second Susan Ryeland (Lesley Manville) and Atticus Pünd (Tim McMullan) mystery in the series (Marble Hall Murders published in May 2025 is the third and possibly final book in the series).

Moonflower Murders begins with Susan Ryeland lured back to England by a couple whose daughter has gone missing after she announced she knew who murdered a guest at her parent’s hotel eight years ago. The daughter had read Atticus Pund Takes the Case and claimed a clue in the book reveals the real killer. And then, she disappeared.

The frantic parents offer Susan Ryeland £10,000 to try to find their missing daughter. The hotel on Crete that Susan and her boyfriend Andreas (Alexandros Logothetis) are operating is struggling. And infusion of cash could save the operation so Susan agrees to investigate. The parents are convinced that Susan–who was the editor for Atticus Pund Takes the Case–will discover the same clue that their daughter did.

Like the first book, Magpie Murders (2016), the chapters alternate between the real world and Atticus Pünd’s fictional world. I’ve enjoyed all three Susan Ryeland and Atticus Pünd mysteries and I’m looking forward to the third PBS series likely to be broadcast in early 2026. GRADE: A

Celebrated Robert E. Howard scholar and contributor to this blog, Fred Blosser, has just done all of the Solomon Kane fans around the world a Big Favor with this instant classic: The Solomon Kane Companion. Last week I refreshed my memory of the Solomon Kane saga by reading The Savage Tales of Solomon Kane (you can read my review here).

Fred’s “informal guide to Robert E. Howard’s Dark Avenger” provides a detailed tour of Howard’s precursor to his legendary Conan the Cimmerian. Solomon Kane is a Puritan wanderer who is obsessed with fighting Evil and righting wrongs. Kane’s adventures involve battling some occult forces. While Kane is an expert swordsman and a deadly shot with his I particularly enjoy when Kane uses his juju staff. Kane’s friend N’Longa, an African shaman, gave Kane a juju staff for protection against evil and to be wielded as a weapon against Dark Magic. Kane uses it to kill vampires and supernatural spirits. In “The Footfalls Within”, it is identified as the mythical Staff of Solomon.

I enjoyed Fred’s analysis of the development of Solomon Kane from story to story. Kane’s adventures begin in 1553 and stop in 1610. But after Robert E. Howard’s death, Solomon Kane stories appeared as pastiches. I remember reading MARVEL’s Solomon Kane series years ago.

Everything you ever wanted to know about Solomon Kane can be found between these pages. Fred Blosser has written a great book about a great character. Don’t miss it! GRADE: A

TABLE OF CONTENTS:

Introduction — vii

CHAPTERS

1. Puritan Marvels and Mysteries — 13
2. King of Swords — 17
3. The Crimson Trails of Solomon Kane: First Phase — 23
4. The Crimson Trails of Solomon Kane: Second Phase — 29
5. The Crimson Trails of Solomon Kane: Third Phase — 35
6. The Crimson Trails of Solomon Kane: Final Phase — 41
7. Damsels Demure, One Damsel Destructive — 45
8. Demons and Devils — 57
9. Despots and Desperados — 69
10. Magi and Men-at-Arms — 81
11. Haunted Places and Lost Cities — 93
12. Variant & Associated Stories in Solomon’s Kane Saga — 105
13. Shrouded in Mystery — 111
14. Solomon Kane and the Lost Continent — 115
15. Dark Avenger versus Eldritch Horrors — 119
16. Did Solomon Kane Ever Meet…? — 123
17. Solomon Kane’s Ruthless Other — 131

APPENDICES

A. SOLOMON KANE in the Comic Books — 137

B. The SOLOMON KANE Concordance –165

C. SOLOMON KANE Chronology — 175

D. Why I Wrote This Book — 181

E. The Essential SOLOMON KANE — 183

F. A Guide to Further Reading — 187

G. Red Shadows — 189

About the Author — 223