FORGOTTEN BOOKS #46: DR. SYN RETURNS By Russell Thorndike

Those of you of a certain age will remember The Scarecrow of Romney Marsh series on Walt Disney’s Wide World of Color in 1964. Patrick McGoohan played both the meek pastor, Dr. Syn, and by night, The Scarecrow, a smuggler with Robin Hood tendencies who donated all his smuggling profits to the poor people of his community. Disney based their series on Russell Thorndike’s adventure novels. I’ve read them all and enjoyed them all. The books have been reprinted many times and should be relatively easy to come by. If you enjoy classic adventure fiction, the Dr. Syn series delivers.

Doctor Syn: A Tale of the Romney Marsh (1915)
Doctor Syn on the High Seas (1935)
Doctor Syn Returns (1936)
Further Adventures of Doctor Syn (1936)
Courageous Exploits of Doctor Syn (1938)
Amazing Quest of Doctor Syn (1939)
Shadow of Doctor Syn (1944)
An expanded version of Doctor Syn Returns titled The Scarecrow Rides was published by The Dial Press in 1935.

18 thoughts on “FORGOTTEN BOOKS #46: DR. SYN RETURNS By Russell Thorndike

  1. Dan

    You’re right, George, a very enjoyable series. The Disney film was fun as well, but I always preferred DR SYN (1940?) George Arliss’ last film. He fit the part well and Roy William Neil’s direction was perfect for it.

    Reply
    1. george Post author

      Disney released a 2-DVD set of DR. SYN: THE SCARECROW OF ROMNEY MARSH in their Disney Treasures series in 2008, Patti. But they only make a certain number of sets, probably 100,000, and now they’re all sold out. Fortunately, my local Library bought a set so I could watch it and relive some old memories.

      Reply
    1. george Post author

      You would like the DR. SYN books, Jeff. I still see copies around from time to time. If you’d like, I’ll ship them to you when I find them.

      Reply
  2. Fred Blosser

    NIGHT CREATURES, a handsome 1961 Hammer film with Peter Cushing and Oliver Reed, was also based on DR. SYN. Reportedly, Disney had already acquired rights to the character, so in the Cushing version he was renamed Blyss. Available on DVD as part of a Hammer set from Universal.

    SCARECROW OF ROMNEY MARSH was based on an odd book, CHRISTOPHER SYN, credited to Russell Thorndike and William Buchanan; Buchanan rewrote and revised one of Thorndike’s earlier Syn titles. As I recall — and maybe this was why Disney used that book and not one of Thorndike’s — Buchanan added a youngster to the cast of characters.

    Used copies of the Thorndike books are pricey, or at least they were a few years ago, even the Arrow and Ballantine paperbacks from the early ’70s.

    Reply
  3. Fred Blosser

    Another bit of trivia: if memory serves, the Beatles’ first performances on the Ed Sullivan Show were parcelled out over three weeks, and all three ran on the same Sunday nights as the three Disney’s Scarecrow episodes. Might even have been on opposite one another; I have a sketchy memory of flipping back and forth between the two channels.

    Reply
    1. george Post author

      Impressive memory, Fred! You’re right: The Beatles were on Ed Sullivan February 1964 which is the same time Disney was broadcasting THE SCARECROW. That might explain why many people missed those episodes.

      Reply
  4. Tom K Mason

    I’ve never read the books, but I love the original series with McGoohan. When I was a kid, I found it creepy and thrilling all at the same time. Even today, pictures of McGoohan in the mask creep me out. It’s a cheap but very effective scare.

    I apologize for the long link (I don’t know how to shorten them), but I thought it was appropriate for the above comments. On a friend of mine’s blog he posts the story of a mutual friend who wanted The Scarecrow but ended up watching The Beatles. His story is toward the bottom of the post (but the whole post is Scarecrow-related)

    http://funnybookfanatic.wordpress.com/2009/01/16/walt-disney-thought-the-scarecrow-was-real-plus-a-fact-you-wont-find-anywhere-else/

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *