
Back in September 2018, motivated by James Wallace Harris, I embarked on rereading the 25-volume The Great SF Stories series edited by Isaac Asimov and Martin H. Greenberg (you can check out the beginning post here). My plan was to reread and review a volume each month and I managed to stay on schedule for the next two-and-half years.
Now, I’m back to reread and review the 25-volume The Best From Fantasy and Science Fiction series. I plan to replicate the one-volume review per month model so this project will be completed in 2023.
This first volume is unique for its inclusion of non-SF writers like Daniel Defoe, Charles Dickens, and Oliver LaFarge. The early issues of The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction regularly reprinted “classic” stories by famous authors.
Here are some of my favorite stories from this anthology:
“Elephas Frumenti” and “The Gift of God” are Gavagan’s Bar stories which L. Sprague de Camp and Fletcher Pratt wrote over the years to the delight of readers. If you like tall tales, you’ll enjoy these shaggy dog stories.
“Old Man Henderson” takes place in a future when Venus and Mars have been colonized, and exotic animals have been imported to the Earth from these planets. Henderson is a retired astronaut, the first man to set foot on the moon, but, instead of being a revered hero, everyone in town is sick of hearing his story of the moon landing and he lives alone, avoided by everyone. Kris Neville illustrates the ephemeral aspects of Fame.
“Dress of White Silk” by Richard Matheson shows the nightmare results of a child’s actions. Matheson would return to this theme in some of his later stories.
As you might suspect, several of these stories are dated. But Boucher and McComas provided material to a growing readership in these genres. A good beginning! GRADE: B
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
Introduction by Anthony Boucher & J. Francis McComas — ix
Huge Beast” (1950) by Cleve Cartmill; — 3
“John the Revelator” (1951) by Oliver La Farge; — 12
“Elephas Frumenti” (1950) by L. Sprague de Camp and Fletcher Pratt; — 27
“The Gift of God” (1950) by L. Sprague de Camp and Fletcher Pratt; — 33
“The Friendly Demon” (1726) by Daniel Defoe; — 40
“Old Man Henderson” (1951) by Kris Neville; — 45
“The Threepenny-Piece” (1913) by James Stephens; — 58
“No-Sided Professor” (1947) by Martin Gardner; — 68
“The Listening Child” (1950) by Margaret St. Clair [as by Idris Seabright]; — 82
“Dress of White Silk” (1951) by Richard Matheson; — 94
“The Mathematical Voodoo” (1951) by H. Nearing, Jr.; — 100
“Hub” (1951) by Philip MacDonald; — 120
“Built Up Logically” (1949) by Howard Schoenfeld; — 126
“The Rat That Could Speak” (1860) by Charles Dickens; — 139
“Narapoia” [Dr. Manly J. Departure]” (1948) by Alan Nelson; — 145
“Postpaid to Paradise” (1940) by Robert Arthur; — 153
“In the Days of Our Fathers” (1949) by Winona McClintic; — 170
“Barney” (1951) by Will Stanton; — 178
“The Collector” (1951) by H. F. Heard; ” — 181
“Fearsome Fable” (1951) by Bruce Elliott — 214











