National Public Radio had a story on the Best 150 Music Albums By Women. You can see the entire list here. Here’s the list’s Top 10 Albums:
1. Joni Mitchell. BLUE, 1971.
2. Lauryn Hill. THE MISEDUCATION OF LAURYN HILL, 1998.
3. Nina Simon. I PUT A SPELL ON YOU, 1965.
4. Aretha Franklin. I NEVER LOVED A MAN THE WAY THE LOVE YOU, 1967.
5. Missy Elliot. SUPA DUPA FLY, 1997.
6. Beyonce. LEMONADE, 2016.
7. Patti Smith. HORSES, 1975.
8. Janis Joplin. PEARL, 1971.
9. Amy Winehouse. BACK TO BLACK, 2006.
10. Carole King. TAPESTRY, 1971.
What do you think of this list? Do you have a favorite music album by a woman?
My favorites would have put something by Marianne Faithful, The Pretenders or a Lucinda Williams. Not a big fan of Beyoncé, Joni Mitchell or Missy Elliot.
Steve, I fell in love with Marianne Faithful back in the Sixties.
Also realized nothing on the 150 long list by Aimee Mann but yet Spice Girls and Brittany Spears make it?
I feel like you, Steve!
I liked the early songs of Natalie Merchant too – haven’t heard from her for some time though.
Funnily enough, my wife doesn’t like female singers too much – is she jealous maybe? Though of course there’s no reason for that …
Wolf, Natalie Merchant has a distinct voice that made 10,000 Maniacs great. She had a successful solo career for a few years, too.
Steve, I noticed that Aimee Mann’s absence, too.
The albums that mean the most to be are from my teenage years when I played them to death. But since 45s were the standard then, they would most be compilations of music from the Shirelles, the Ronettes, the Chifons, etc. The first real albums I bought were ones by Judy Collins, Joan Baez, Barbra Streisant and Carol King.
Patti, the first album I bought was Bob Dylan’s HIGHWAY 61 REVISITED. But I did buy all of Joni Mitchell’s albums. My favorite was COURT & SPARK.
I am frankly appalled by the top 10.
*gets back on geezer bus*
Jeff, I wasn’t thrilled with their TOP 10 ALBUMS BY WOMEN ARTISTS, either. I would have voted for TAPASTRY to be NUMBER ONE.
I agree. I’d have TAPESTRY up there, and COURT & SPARK in the Top Ten.
Yoko Ono? Oh, no.
Britney Spears? No.
The Spice Girls inclusion is unforgivable, let alone at #64 ahead of people who can actually, you know, sing. This is supposed to be the Greatest Albums, not crap that sold a lot to 8 year old girls.
I’m not going to insult the stuff I don’t know, but come on.
Joni Mitchell, Court and Spark
Emmylou Harris, Elite Hotel or one of several others
Linda Ronstadt, Prisoner in Disguise
The Shirelles, Greatest Hits
And how can you have a list like this and not even a mention of Patsy Cline?
Jeff, Linda Ronstadt should be in the TOP 10.
I can remember sitting in my room as a teenager with Joni’s latest album playing over and over again while I gulped down the lyrics. I know the words to every song on every Joni Mitchell album until about 1982-ish. However, I wouldn’t put BLUE at the top of this list–I wouldn’t even put BLUE as the best of Joni’s albums. I’d reserve that spot for FOR THE ROSES, which was where she was really segueing into a more jazz-infused sound.
Deb, like you I know all the words to those early Joni Mitchell albums including BLUE. But I can only listen to BLUE about once a year. It’s just too sad for me to listen to, especially when she sings about giving up her child.
I didn’t know a lot of the lower half of the list. I agree with Jeff, why no Patsy Cline, and why Yoko. Britney and Spice girls (girl power? most feminists rail at the word girl rather than women, and these were IIRC grown women)
What surprised me was that it wasn’t just for women singers on their own, but in groups with men, but with the women as the singers, and strength of the group, it made sense.
Of the top ten, my favorites were Aretha, Joplin, and Carole King.
Maggie, I love Aretha, Joplin, and Carole King!
Me too!
Bought all their LPs – so many great “girls”/women – never understood the fascination for Spice Girls etc.
A woman who was interested in them or even a fan would have been a no-no for me. 🙂
But I’m too old anyway for the “new” concept of pop music (and that goes for other stuff too tv, movies, books, you name it …) – lots of hype, all show, all fake, no substance!
Wolf, most of the stuff played on the radio today is “fake music.”
I always liked this, from Jimmy Buffett’s “Miss You So Badly”:
I got a head of full of feelin’ higher
And an ear full of Patsy Cline
There is just no one who can touch her
Hell I’ll hang on every line.
You don’t hear anyone saying that about Britney, or Janet Jackson for that matter.
Jeff, Britney and Janet are the musical equivalent of “junk food.”
I didn’t look at the long list, but no Ella or Billie Holiday in the top 10 invalidates it for me.
Rick, this list had a definite “pop” bias.
And mostly newer pop/rock…for some reason, their selections have to date from 1963 or later, but 1960s pop icons are thin on the list. Frankly, up and down the list, jazz and folk artists are definitely underrepresented as well, and even Aretha Franklin probably doesn’t deserve multiple albums in this context, given all the people left out. I’ve suggested elsewhere that this is a very ROLLING STONE magazine-style list, mixing the pop for relatively young nostalgia buffs with the Very mildly exotic (but nothing too challenging). Utterly unsurprising they should land on Miriam Makeba’s PATA PATA, probably her greatest commercial hit, for example, as her representation here.
Sorry, 1064 or later…Beatles in US nostalgia? A list, as I joked elsewhere, devoted to music I could possibly have heard when it was still new?
Or, even, 1964. Nobody knew this typing thin was so hard.
Todd, I completely agree. This is a very homogenized list.
I understand the objections to this list but I have to say that I’ve always considered Blue to be one of the best pop/rock albums of all time.
joe allegretti
Joseph, I agree with you on BLUE. But I can’t stand to listen to it very often. It’s just too sad.